Page 1 of 3

Top 10 War Planes

Posted: 27 Apr 2007, 18:50
by Falker
For all you air jocks.



From Space.com




Image
This Mitsubishi is looking nicely restored.

Never to be ranked among the sturdiest planes in history, Japan's long-range fighter the Mitsubishi Zero was built purely for speed and maneuverability. Its brittle aluminum body was very light and could dip and dive better than any other plane during World War II. The Zero would become the cornerstone of Japan's suicide "kamikaze" squadrons.

Posted: 28 Apr 2007, 12:37
by Grifter
Great pictures. The list itself however is totally bogus. Look what ranked number 1. snort.

Posted: 28 Apr 2007, 14:45
by PanzerMeyer
UCAV #1??? WTF?

Doesn't matter. All of these "top 10" lists whether they be for airplanes or music albums or PC games or whatever are totally useless.

Posted: 28 Apr 2007, 18:05
by Grifter
I say we make our own top ten Fighter A/C list.

Posted: 28 Apr 2007, 18:49
by PanzerMeyer
Grifter wrote:I say we make our own top ten Fighter A/C list.
Ok, I'll start it off with #10


I made the same mistake as Buffalo Six. It's top 10 FIGHTERS.

Ok, my contribution will be: FW-190A

Posted: 28 Apr 2007, 19:11
by Hudson
Tempest and P-38 will be on it, damnit

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 07:34
by VEGETA
the fun part is I see these lits, on Tv, on the net and when it comes to war planes, the list always ends with American aircraft over everything else. and to top it off not American aircraft I would use to top off a list anyway. also note you almost never see any Russian WW2 aircraft, or there later model aircraft on that list either as some of there newest toys are easialy as maneuverable as the f22, just no stealth. I always feal these lists are biased per the country that came up with it, at least when it comse to th top locations on the lists.

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 08:02
by Mooseman
The Hurricane..for doing the job that it had to do, whilst the Spitfire nicked all the glory

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 08:08
by Buffalo Six
I'd put the B52 on the list....born in 1953ish and still on duty

Opps...you said top 10 fighters

Well my top 10 would be (in no order, off the top of my head)

P51D
Spit (all versions)
Zero
Me109 (all versions)
P-47
F-86
F-16
F-15
F-4
Mig 15

Honorable mention....F4u Corsair, FW190, F14, F18, Mig21, Mig 29

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 08:16
by Mooseman
On the subject of fighter planes, this pilot is an old pupil from my school....
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Johnnie_Jo ... 28pilot%29

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 10:03
by daofcmacg
OK what was that list there, whoever wrote that didn't even look at the tempest, P-38, Corsair (I know but you got to love the black sheep LoL), the hawker Hurricane, and the FW-190 Wolfe (now that's a plane's plane).


DA

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 12:26
by Hammer
Buff - no flankers???

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 12:47
by Buffalo Six
what do slot backs have to do with warplanes? 8)

Like I said that was off the top of my head and my main criteria was did in some way change the face of air combat? I think I picked 10 that did that to an extent

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 13:27
by Tach Deneva
SE5A
Fokker D.VII
SPAD S.XIII
RZ-1 A-wing
TIE Avenger

PDT_Armataz_01_30

TD

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 13:59
by VEGETA
se5a was not anything special, it was arguabley the best plane in 1918, but just bigger engine and such, nothing extra. the Fokker if I remember right was the first to have the timing thing to shoot through the prop.

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 14:32
by Grifter
A few years ago, "Wings" tried to do a top ten of all time and even they conceded that thier finalized list was not perfect because they had to cut something. Many would've put the F-14 in for example for its BVR and unusual folding wing design, but some would argue that would not be enough and argue F-5 Tiger is an absolute must have for some reason. shrug. Well, there will always be different opinions about which planes belong on the list. I'll consider what should go on my list. For starters, I'd say the F-14 belongs and Vought F8U Crusader

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 14:54
by Jedi Master
Yes, the "Eindecker". First they just had metal plates to deflect the bullets, then they made the "interrupter gear."

For my list:
MiG-29
Su-27
F-15
P-51
P-38
Bf109
AV-8
F-14
Spitfire
F-22 (sort of future tense, there :) )

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 17:44
by Falker
Image


I believe the A-10 Warthog ( aka A-10 Thunderbolt ) should be on the list.

The 'Warthog' is exceptionally hardy, to the point that it could be considered an airborne tank. Its strong airframe can survive direct hits from armor-piercing and high-explosive projectiles up to 23 mm. The aircraft has triple redundancy in its flight systems, with mechanical systems to back up double-redundant hydraulic systems which permits pilots to fly and land when hydraulic power is lost. The aircraft is designed to fly with one engine and half a wing torn off.

The A-10 was shown when USAF Captain Kim Campbell, flying a ground support mission over Baghdad during the 2003 invasion of Iraq suffered extensive flak damage to her A-10. The hit damaged one of the A-10's two engines and destroyed its hydraulic system, disabling the plane's stabilizer and flight controls. Despite this, the pilot managed to fly it for an hour and landed it safely at the air base in manual reversion mode.


Image
The A-10 Warthog is a fighter/bomber that is used by NATO and can also can hold a wide
assortment of weapons, up to 16,000 pounds of them on the wings!

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 18:05
by Falker
When does the RLG or “Elf-Who“ top ten list come out anyway? (That’s WOF & ELH for short.) Umm 1- 2-3 weeks?

After everyone chips in we'll let PanzerMeyer calculate the final top ten. :wink:

Posted: 30 Apr 2007, 18:18
by daofcmacg
Looking at people's varied list then we need a speciality categories and otwo categories in paticular would be multi-role and dual role aircraft (to me dual role means an aircraft that is designated multiple roles but can only do one role effectively versus multi-role where an aircraft excels at all roles that it has been designated). I noticed no one thru in any Israelie aircraft so I will.

With what we started here we could actually write a book on the subject detailing each category and every aircraft in that category then going into ellaborate detail about each aircraft giving the aircrafts history and such.