My Review for new X-Files movie
Posted: 28 Jul 2008, 05:12
As some of you here may know, I consider myself to be a hardcore fan of the X-Files. It's one of my top three favorite shows of all time and I even spent the big bucks to get the new Ultimate edition dvd set of the entire series last Christmas. So this review of mine has turned out to be quite different from what I was expecting.
Watching this movie was quite a revelation to me and one that filled me with an unnerving combination of delight and disappointment. In my humble opinion, this movie was really made for the fans of the show and no one else. The central story of the movie could have easily been made as a 2 parter episode on tv. It just didn't have that epic and compelling story that would be worthy of a theatrical release. I was very pleased with the performances by Duchovny and Anderson as well as Billy Connolly and Callum Keith Renne. The acting was fine, the dialogue was good and the movie really did have a compelling dark mood to it. In the final analysis however, there really was nothing there that I felt would entice people to watch the movie who were not already fans of the show.
As it stands now, this should have been a direct to dvd release. However, it didn't have to be that way. I really think this movie could have attracted more people had it had a more sci-fi and epic scale to it involving government conspiracies, aliens, etc. I'm trying not to provide any bona fide spoilers here but the story in actuality had very little sci-fi in it and there was a supernatural element which only involved one character.
Final verdict,
If you are a fan of the show you should watch it and if you never cared for the show or if you only had a casual interest in it you shouldn't bother.
Watching this movie was quite a revelation to me and one that filled me with an unnerving combination of delight and disappointment. In my humble opinion, this movie was really made for the fans of the show and no one else. The central story of the movie could have easily been made as a 2 parter episode on tv. It just didn't have that epic and compelling story that would be worthy of a theatrical release. I was very pleased with the performances by Duchovny and Anderson as well as Billy Connolly and Callum Keith Renne. The acting was fine, the dialogue was good and the movie really did have a compelling dark mood to it. In the final analysis however, there really was nothing there that I felt would entice people to watch the movie who were not already fans of the show.
As it stands now, this should have been a direct to dvd release. However, it didn't have to be that way. I really think this movie could have attracted more people had it had a more sci-fi and epic scale to it involving government conspiracies, aliens, etc. I'm trying not to provide any bona fide spoilers here but the story in actuality had very little sci-fi in it and there was a supernatural element which only involved one character.
Final verdict,
If you are a fan of the show you should watch it and if you never cared for the show or if you only had a casual interest in it you shouldn't bother.